Florentino Pérez, the fast-talking and even faster-spending president of Real Madrid, has raised the spectre of a European Super League consisting of the continent’s biggest and richest clubs.
Pérez’s immediate objective is to persuade Michel Platini, the Uefa president, to guarantee the presence of Europe’s marquee names in the Champions League, but has threatened to push for a breakaway league if his proposals are rejected.
The problem with the status quo — speaking commercially now, and God knows that club bosses see the world in such terms — is simple: Europe’s top teams play against each other too seldom. A Super League replacing the existing European and domestic fixtures would allow Europe’s best teams to play against each other twice a week, providing them with huge additional income.
I don't see the super league threat as a risk to domestic football. As much as the Berlusconi's and Perez's might bemoan having to play against lower clubs, I think they realise the importance of the domestic competitions in providing a stronger identity for fans to latch on to.
I also think that if the top clubs did form a break away league and withdrew from domestic and UEFA competitions. You would probably end up with the same problems domestic competitions face today. A club or group of clubs would become dominant. How long would Milan stay in a super league if Madrid, Manchester United and Chelsea were constantly the top 3 teams for 5-10 years? Would a club like Milan really make more money playing in a super league if they lost every week?
I believe that the super league threats are solely a way of keeping rebel romanticist Michel Platini in line. Since his rise to power as president of UEFA he has set about bringing to life his Utopian image of what football should be. A lot of Platini's plans strike at the heart of the top clubs dominance of power and money. Platini has already been made to compromise on some of his larger plans, like the changes to qualification to the Champions League and I think Perez wants to mark his return to Madrid, not only by buying as many big name players as possible, but by becoming the face of the big clubs fight against Platini.
If the big clubs did break away it would destroy UEFA's power. A break away competition could even threaten the participation of clubs and national teams in FIFA competitions. Perez and co. are just trying to make it clear to Platini that he can have his time in the spotlight, but they are the real power.